MARKETING AT ANY COST
C.J. Hayden, MCC
"Will this marketing approach be
worth my while?" It's a question independent professionals often ask. But there's a related
question that, unfortunately, they ask much less often: "How much will it cost compared to what it
brings in?" Surprisingly few professionals know the answer to this crucial question, and many
admit it had simply never occurred to them.
Every marketing approach has a set
of costs attached. Display ads, pay-per-click campaigns, and trade show exhibits come with a price
tag. Association meetings, networking mixers, and business lunches have registration fees, incur
food and travel expenses, and take up your time. Websites, brochures, and flyers consume time and
money to design, launch, and print. And so on.
But what is the relationship of
this spending to the new business it's intended to generate? How much does a new client really
cost? Let's explore some examples. This will require a bit of math, but don't let that scare you
off. Instead, pull out your calculator and follow along.
If it costs you $250 in marketing
expenses to land a $250 sale, is that a worthwhile investment? Some professionals think it is. For
some reason, they don't see that this means they are working for free. Instead, they mistakenly
believe they are breaking even.
Let's factor in your direct costs
for delivering your product or service — those expenses you only incur once you make a sale,
and which aren't reimbursed by your client. Depending on what you do, this might include
inventory, supplies, gas, parking, phone charges, out-of-town travel, space rental, audiovisual
materials, processing fees, shipping, subcontractor labor, your assistant's wages, or credit card
fees.
Then if your marketing expenses
total $200 to make a $250 sale, and your direct costs for delivering that product or service total
$50, now it is worth it? The answer is still no. You've been reimbursed for your costs, but you
haven't yet been compensated for your time.
What if costs you only $100 in
marketing to make a $250 sale, your direct costs are $50, and it takes three hours to deliver the
product or service? Now is it worth it? Only if you value your professional time at less than
$33 per hour. ($250 minus $150 equals $100, divided by 3 hours equals $33 per hour.)
In the example above, your direct
cost of sales has been covered, as has your marketing cost. But your hourly rate still needs to
pay for all your other business expenses, health insurance, taxes, and the myriad other financial
components of being self-employed. If you can work for $33 per hour, pay your expenses, and still
have enough left over to live on, you can afford to pay $100 for a $250 sale. But if you can't,
that kind of marketing will quickly make you go broke.
So far, we've been looking only at
the hard costs of marketing — what you pay money for. But many marketing approaches also
take a considerable amount of time. What's the cost of that? Here's a quick way to find out.
Let's say you want your business to
bring in a total of $80,000 in revenue this year, you'd like to take four weeks vacation, and work
a total of forty hours per week. $80,000 divided by 48 weeks equals $1667 per week, divided by 40
hours equals $42 per hour. That means every single hour you spend working in your business, you
need to be earning $42. If you spend an hour on marketing for which you aren't being paid, that's
$42 you'll have to earn at some other time.
If you spend four hours marketing
to land a $250 sale, and it takes three hours to deliver the product or service you sold, you're
only earning $36 per hour. At that rate, you'll never be able to make $80K. You'll either top out
at $69K ($36 multiplied by 40 hours, multiplied by 48 weeks equals $69,000), or you'll have to
work an extra 6 hours per week to make up the difference.
Okay, I know this a lot of math to
follow, so here's my point in a few words. Nothing in marketing is worth doing "at any cost." The
next time someone tries to convince you that buying an ad, launching a new website, attending an
event, or joining a networking group is an absolute must... determine first what the true cost of
that choice will be.
Estimate the number of hours it
will take to employ the approach you're considering. Multiply the estimated hours by your
requirement for earnings per hour, as calculated above. Add that total to the amount of hard money
you'll need to spend. That will give you the true cost of marketing.
Now, how much will this new
marketing approach need to produce in sales in order to be worth your while? There's no one
formula that will work for every type of business, but here's an example.
You're considering joining a lead
exchange group that meets weekly. The quarterly membership fee is $150, you'll need to drive 10
miles each way to get there and pay for parking, and each meeting you attend will take 2 1/2 hours
of your time. A rough estimate of the cost per quarter might be $1700 ($150 plus $185 for
mileage/parking plus $1365 for your time, valued at $42 per hour from the example above).
If a typical client project for you
totals $1500, and you land one project per quarter as a result of this group, you'll be losing
money. That's a sobering thought. Before doing the math, you might have believed that four new
clients per year would make attending this group worthwhile.
What if you land two projects per
quarter at $1500 each? First, notice that each of these sales has a marketing cost of $850 ($1700
divided by 2). If each $1500 project would entail $100 in direct costs, you'll net $550 per
project ($1500 minus $950). If each project takes 18 hours of your time to accomplish, your net
earnings will be $31 per hour. You'll never be able to make your income goal of $80K.
In this example, you'd have to land
three new $1500 projects each quarter — one new client per month — for your
investment in this group to become worthwhile. Then your marketing cost per client would be only
$567, you'd net $833 per project, and earn $46 per hour, $4 more than the required hourly earnings
to meet your goal.
If you believe that participating
in this group will deliver one new $1500 project per month, you've just identified a worthwhile
marketing approach. But if you believe that 12 clients per year is too much to expect, or that
you'd actually need to spend even more time and money on having coffee and lunch with other group
members to see that kind of payoff, you'd better forget about the leads group and consider a
different idea.
Whew! That was a lot of
calculating. If math isn't your strong point, you might be tempted to skip this whole exercise and
just take a gamble. But really, wouldn't you rather spend 15 minutes running some numbers than
spend six months trying a new marketing approach, and then find out it's costing you more
than it will ever bring in?
Copyright
© 2009, C.J. Hayden
Read more free articles by
C.J. Hayden or subscribe to the GET
CLIENTS NOW! E-Letter.
Editors, publishers & webmasters: You may reprint these articles
free of charge if you follow our reprint
guidelines.
COMMENTS FROM OUR READERS
"C.J., great job explaining the math behind the opportunities! Such an important lesson for
entrepreneurs to learn — and so many don't get it. Thanks for all of your hard work to
help make the world a more profitable place!"
— Cynthia D'Amour, MBA, Leadership Strategist, Ann Arbor, MI
"I really 'get' this reasoning on ROI and see how easy it is to actually be giving away
money rather than making anything by not running the numbers as you have here... Thank you
for a great article."
— Tshombe Brown, CoachingforRealEstateAgents.com, Portland, OR
|
|